I mean episode 13 they adapted an entire volume into 1 episode. The same can be said of series like Honey & Clover and Monster, one can respect the quality of the original source, yet when I think of those series, I think of a spinning ferris wheel, dotted with beautiful lights, and Johan’s blonde hair and sad voice, all of them images from their respective anime. The Fullmetal Alchemist manga and anime series feature an extensive cast of fictional characters created by Hiromu Arakawa.The story is set in a fictional universe within the 20th century in which alchemy is one of the most advanced scientific techniques. I guess that is what happens when not only do you have a manga to compare to but also another anime series (at least now that we have reached manga only territory you can’t really compare this new series to the first anime anymore). We get it, Ed doesn't like being called short or people thinking Al is the Fullmetal Alchemist. I never liked Full Metal Alchemist, the dialouge was boring, fights were weak, the main charachters were annoyig. I assure you manga Kimblee is more appealing than FMAB Kimblee.) Just have to say that if I were new to FMA to begin with, “Brotherhood” would piss me off and turn me away. Edward and Alphonse Elric are two brothers living in a world where the practice of alchemy flourishes. In this case, the complaining has particularly confused me because I’m genuinely enjoying the adaptation; it doesn’t feel rushed at all, which is why I think the (manga) fandom should be trying to view Brotherhood as a separate entity, because it is turning out to be a good series with great production values, and it would be a shame to pick it apart and complain every week rather than just enjoying it for what it is (I suppose I just want everyone to enjoy it!) Plus it resonates well with an English-speaking audience (most of MAL), due to the culture, setting, and a pretty great dub by FUNIMATION. Regardless, it’s great discussing FMA with as passionate a fan as you, and we’re on totally different sides of the fence this time, which makes the debate all the more fascinating. Underneath his eye patch is \"The Ultimate Eye\", or his regular eye with the Ouroboros mark in place of the pupil and cornea. Having been badly effected by the Bokurano adaptation, I ended up dropping it and feeling bitterly let down by the whole thing, but months later, I had another go and realised it wasn’t that bad after all. The beginning episodes that we had already pretty much seen in the first anime I can understand, but once the new characters were introduced it should have slowed down. Say for Eg. But since i didn't read the manga and i liked the movie i go for the old full metal alchemist go go go! @gaguri It’s a good adaption that I’m glad they did. I haven’t read the manga, but I loved the first anime, even when it diverged from the source material, so I’m not someone that demands an adaptation be a frame-for-frame duplicate, it just has to be good! The first FMA run had drama, mystery, and backstory it actually had you hooked. I’d read and loved the novel several times, way before the anime was made, and I was still willing and able to view the anime as a stand-alone – after all, when one sees “anime adaptation,” “24 episodes” and “Gonzo” one should know better than to expect a faithful adaptation. This isn't really so much a comparison to the previous anime. . An adaption should add to the manga not take away from it, which is exactly what this adaption has been doing so far (not that all the episodes were bad I did quite enjoy 4, 8 and 9). I do agree with you though it did move quickly at times but that didn't bother me too much since I read the manga. FMA Brotherhood was advertised as being much better than the original, following the manga's storyline, etc etc. Grey's Anatomy. Is There a Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood Season 2? Anyone familiar with the series? long live fullmetal! I’m totally enjoying this new version, and I don’t want to judge if it’s better or worse. Being born from the Deadly Sin of Wrath, he … Fullmetal Alchemist is an iconic anime that has been recommended countless times over the past decade. it was only after i read the manga and saw fma1 that i realized its flaws but i never bothered. The ending is good also, unlike the original anime series. I checked out the Yutaka Nakamura MAD on YouTube and it was mightily impressive, reminds me that I need to rewatch Wolf’s Rain and RahXephon some time too. I'll watch more of Brotherhood before I start trying to support it in these cases. I know it has some bad words and violence but it is normally the same as the original FMA and the original FMA was TV PG or TV 14. (Sub) The First Day. There's so much history there with me and my friends and such. I tried the manga and found it uninspiring and droll as hell (not dull, just droll), but the first series worked well, even with its multiple flaws. In the first version (Fullmetal Alchemist), the first half of the series is really good. I began watching Brotherhood, I was confused at first, because I wasn’t sure if it was an adaption of continuation, but I realized it was following the manga’s series (which I prefered) I was able to enjoy it again. Honestly it defeats the purpose by nitpicking a series apart just because it doesn’t mirror a manga or book 100% it’s literally impossible, and as you said, they’re the same general ideals just customized to make it unique in it’s own way. To me, this is the key to the success of an adaptation. why fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad. It's finally 2021, but the PS5 isn't any easier to find in stock. Fullmetal Alchemist is the popular anime and manga by Hiromu Arikawa and has made two anime series, several volumes of comics, novels, and even a Netflix adaptation. I am a lot disappointed because there are no cards at all with Lin Yao, Pride, Wrath, Kimblee, Scar, etc. (In fact, I consider ‘Gankutsuou’ the best adaptation of ‘Monte Cristo’ that I’ve seen so far, and I’ve seen quite a few… and with the exception of ‘Gankutsuou’ I hate all of them.) @AnimeNerdz Perhaps it’s that the first anime adaptation was it’s own work, and went its own way. Since you don’t know what you are missing you also don’t understand what the complaints are precisely about. so, i basically do not want to comapare the two series as both are close to my heart and have been great support during bad times. It was a shame that they cut his badass line: “How rude! Many other people have stated that they didn't enjoy FMA Brotherhood as well. It follows the Elric brothers, who are on a journey to find the fabled philosopher's stone in order to make wrong they accomplished in trying to bring their mother back. Of course there’s a limit to everything, and while I love ‘Gankutsou,’ ‘RomeoxJuliet’ made me roll my eyes. This topic is locked from further discussion. FMAB is good to, worth watching. Search, discover and share your favorite Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood GIFs. Honestly I have to agree with Bateszi. but i could appreaciate it only cuz i seperated it from the manga and brotherhood. also,the absence of Bones no.1 animator (imo best animator ever Yutaka nakamura Al contrario que la primera versión del anime, esta cubriría… This is actually the first anime I plan to watch completely, so I disagree with you for now, but I've only seen a couple of episodes so far. In my opinion, the reason why Fullmetal Alchemist is considered so good has to do with three things: The solid characters. I guess it’s unfair for me to compare the new FMA series to Gankutsuou. I don't want to say it, but... it really just turned into generic anime about good guys beating bad guys, maybe a little bit of 'working together' elements thrown in, and that's it. Well, the bad thing about the original series is the ending. Summary: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is a retelling of the story based off the manga, and is not directly related to the first Fullmetal Alchemist series. I thought FMAB was a great anime though I will admit that is a true inconsistancy. I need to find a way to stop him from watching this. However the ending wasn’t very satisfying as many of you have said. I watched episode 14 earlier this evening and for the first time in a while, something really violent and twisted happened that I’d totally forgotten about (hint: it involves King Bradley, a sword and Al’s ’empty’ suit of armour). The first fourteen episodes of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood received criticism from members of the Anime News Network staff, who said that repeating events from the first anime led to a lack of suspense. There is no character development, there is no reason for me to care about the characters, and I think the anime moved way too quickly. Gankutsuou is obviously an extreme example to compare to a mainstream hit like FMA, but the spirit of the former is wonderful, so much so in fact that it feels like an original work. I don’t mind if It’s not a panel by panel adaptation, I don’t care if it’s a completely different story, just be careful not to advertise yourself as such. Like Gankutsuou! FMA is a bit more dramatic. it’s not like someone will actually care what they think…. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. I have to agree with you, my dear author. the show isnt over theres one more episode. A lot of 1st anime fans have been complaining too. It's been 5 years, so I don't remember the first anime so much as I remember the fond memories I had at the time. Naruto. I’d can’t agree with that, hence this post, really. Studio BONES has had problems with tonal control sometimes, with RahXephon and Fullmetal Alchemist often suffering from it, but Brotherhood suffers the most. In this new version, character introduction is more straight to the point, there isn’t enough room for suspense like we had in the original. Is it really that good? It’s always nice to hear from an old blogging acquaintance! Your email address will not be published. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 57 Turn on Captions for English Subs. and should i watch it over reading the manga? ... She spends her free time rereading the same five books over and over, being bad at video games (only when other people are watching), and desperately trying to get her friends to play board games with her. Determined to find the Philosopher's Stone, the Elric brothers confront Cornello … Could someone tell me the ending? © 2021 GAMESPOT, A RED VENTURES COMPANY. Exactly! Both Fullmetal Alchemist and Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood (follows the manga (comic)) are great in their own ways and are a must see anime for children, teens, and adults (I would say a 10 year old could handle the content, but it probably depends more on the parent than the child). So in that regards the pacing was kind of screwed up. So we are already VERY familiar with the characters, including their nature and role.

fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad 2021